This book is big, and
I mean it is 8x10 inches, and there are full page photographs in it so it feels
like both a collection of poems and a photo album, both things that can be
captured and things that can’t. This book is big, and I mean opening it is like
opening a map of the sky, with millions of little dots connecting over time and
space:
Draw a line through / our scattered
bodies / the meadow reveals / our constellation
This is the entirety
of Lopez, Praying Herd: Requiem. I
love this poem for its spacing of each individual concept like stars that hold
a bigger picture when viewed together. What we see when we look at stars is
light from billions of years ago. The stars themselves don’t exist in the same
time we do, they’re dead. But we can still see them, and that’s always struck
me as very beautiful, and symbolic—that what we see and experience in our lives
is created from and intimately connected to the past. Villarreal’s work, through
its rich imagery of stars, pines, canyons, and beasts, plays a lot with connections
to the past, her own past and the past of those who came before her all play
out in one big book.
This connection to
the past is especially important in confronting assimilation, which disconnects from everything, like being locked in a dark room. The series of
poems: Assimilation Rooms, Assimilation
Progress Report, and Gulf Pines, or Final Assimilation Room were very
powerful to read, as with each poem, the violence and depersonalization of
assimilation over time becomes more pronounced, from being locked in a
classroom, to being locked in a mental hospital.
Villarreal includes footnotes in this section, which is notable as they’re typically only found in scientific writing and academic
papers. “Citing your sources” is a way of asserting your expertise on a subject,
a demonstration of your authority and adherence to institutional procedure.
That Villarreal cites sources in poetry, in a huge blur of text on page 34, seems to ask how
these papers, written by the same people who are responsible for inflicting the
violence of assimilation on her, could have the power to say anything more about her experience than she can say in her own poetry:
“This association is purported to
reflect, in part, the impact of negative experiences faced by immigrants in the
process of assimilation, i.e. acculturative stressors. However, these findings
can be explained by high levels of risk for psychiatric disorder among the
US-born members of ethnic minority populations, who have both high risk for
psychiatric disorders and high levels of acculturation relative to immigrants.”
Repeated over and
over, blurred until indecipherable, mirroring psychological dissociation, the insanity of the assimilator seen by the assimilated, a challenge to ‘parallax’: the
effect of position upon viewing an object.
“use parallax in / a poem b
minus”
“the tricks of English tricks of the trade”
Maggie,
ReplyDeleteYou are hitting the nail on the head, so to speak.This is a book that disrupts the tropes of life and death and assimilation. Nice job. Elmaz
Thank you so much for saying this: "That Villarreal cites sources in poetry, in a huge blur of text on page 34, seems to ask how these papers, written by the same people who are responsible for inflicting the violence of assimilation on her, could have the power to say anything more about her experience than she can say in her own poetry."
ReplyDeleteI was wrestling this week with the function of journalistic citation in Villarreal's poetry. For me, these footnotes feel like evidence needed to back up a case, as if her existence and identity needs justification to society. I appreciate how you've pointed out the impact of the blurred, repetitive citation and the message it conveys -- it reads like, "you can take this *beloved* citation and eat it one million times, and choke on it."
yes, I like your interpretation of the citations in Assimilation rooms. For me it is about the white space of clinical language asserting her condition, rendering her nameless and dehumanizing her experience. The blur of the diagnosis of what she experiences overwritten into illegibility either to reflect her Resistance to their assertions, that it their words are meaningless in describing her actual experience or to reflect the ways that their words are an erasure of her humanity
ReplyDelete