Sunday, February 3, 2019

Response to Morgan Parker’s There Are More Beautiful Things Than Beyoncé




            I’m just going to start by throwing out some of the lines from this collection that stuck with me. From My Vinyl Weighs a Ton: “The sun bends it’s back over Struggle City.” And “It’s just one long slumber party in here. It seems impossible/that Mom will ever arrive, car running, to take me home.” From White Beyoncé: “Her daughter learns about beauty/Discovers nothing surprising”. From Welcome to the Jungle: “All Men Have Been Created Equally/To Shiver At The Thought Of Me” and “one of these days my whole body might just//go away like just standing in line at Whole Foods or purgatory”. And from Afro: “a Zulu folktale warning against hunters drunk on Polo shirts and Jägermeister.”
            These are small pieces from a collection that blended musical references and dark, self-deprecating humor, into poems that were both very lyrical and luxurious. I say luxurious, because though many of them were laced with pain, I also felt that they in some way embodied the idea of ‘self-care’. The material luxuries in her work: the baths, champagne, nail polish, lipstick, pills, etc. as well as the musicality and humor scattered throughout, are defenses against emotional stressors. But they are also ways to acknowledge and confront them. The act of writing poetry is itself a form of ‘self-care’, not just charcoal masking the pain away, but feeling it, trying to make sense of it, and putting it outside of yourself so it doesn’t have to stay just on the inside.
            Parkers use of spacing for me either indicate pauses in the flow or implied words. In The President Has Never Said the Word Black, what is implied by the spaces in the line “we lost a young boy today,” between ‘young’ and ‘boy’ is the unsayable. In 13 Ways of Looking at a Black Girl, where Parker lists near thirty names, adjectives, and phrases used to describe black girls, the only word that comes up exactly 13 times is ‘sex’. The spacing in this poem feels erratic, every one or two words are separated by gaps, and each gap seems like it’s filled with the word ‘sex’. It’s been scattered so thoroughly through the poem that it seems to fill every crack.
Take a Walk on the Wild Side also made interesting use of spacing: “I feel the bass you-know-where [                  ] exactly,” leaves space for the reader to imagine where she might feel it, or where they themselves feel it, or where to imagine the bass at other parts in the poem. I had forgotten the title until I got to the final line of this poem, “And the colored girls go:” the colon leaving a huge open-ended space that my brain filled up with the end of Take a Walk on the Wild Side, with doo doo doo’s fading into the distance. So, I listened to the song, and looked at the poem again, and then looked up the song lyrics, and looked at the poem again, and thought about Parker replacing the doo doo doo’s with the voice of an actual black woman.
Parker’s work feels intimate: brimming with pop-culture, sexual desire, and identity politics, Parker’s world is our world, and it is consuming. Her poetry is exploration of her own identity as a black woman, as an artist, as an American, and she navigates all of this beautifully and unapologetically.

Ennui, Alcohol and Punctuation in "There Are More Beautiful Things Than Beyonce"


The last line of the final poem in There Are More Beautiful Things Than Beyoncé asks: “Why do you get up in the morning”. It is a question without a question mark, a question that hangs heavy with empty space, too exhausted to inflect or upturn itself. It makes me think back to “99 Problems” and how #99 reads “I’m tired.” And how what Beyonce won’t say on a therapist’s couch is “what if I said I’m tired / and they heard wrong / said sing it”

Throughout the poems, there is a constant feeling of malaise and why bother. I think about the first poem, “All They Want is My Pussy My Money My Blood” and how each sentence only occupies one line, the space in-between like a long sigh. The stacking of these lines and the regularity in structure creates an equalizing quality, providing the same weight and importance to “I have a nose ring I forget about” and “There are far too many of me dying” or “I could die any minute of depression.”

Alcohol provides perpetual and slushy texture to this work: “When I drink anything / out of a martini glass / I feel untouched by / professional and sexual / rejection,” “You wash up on a barstool,” “A sip of liquor from a creek,””What to a woman is the bottom of a glass,” “All Men Have Been Created Equally / To Shiver At The Thought Of Me / is something I used to think but forgot / or got drunk tried smoking something new.” Sex is everywhere, too: “I just want to have sex most of the time.”

Both alcohol and sex are depicted as both a need and a distraction, and this is exactly the point. It makes me think about ennui, the various crutches we all depend on to make it through the day. But ennui is typically a product of the elite. As far as I understand it, boredom was basically “invented” by the Victorian aristocracy, because they had delegated all the labor to other people and internalized commodified notions about what is important in the world, creating in them a kind of emotional and spiritual poverty. Who else had the time or the privilege to be bored?  The radical and fascinating thing that I see Parker doing here is inviting the notion of a Black Ennui – how the inescapability of violence and oppression can manifest as a kind of banality, how it can create an exhaustion and despair for black folks that can feel so often like ennui. How you can become bored with death, so much so that it takes on a kind of objectified, frozen beauty: “The most beautiful hearse     / I have ever seen / is parked in front of my stoop / Perched            hands folded for six to eight weeks / twinkling like a siren / a new idea of love,”

I’ll mention, because it keeps running through my head as I write this, the lyrics to Solange’s “Cranes in the Sky,” which I think musically illustrates so much of what I’m trying to express here:

I tried to drink it away
I tried to put one in the air
I tried to dance it away
I tried to change it with my hair
I ran my credit card up
Thought a new dress make it better
I tried to work it away
But that just made me even sadder
I tried to keep myself busy
I ran around circles
Think I made myself dizzy
I slept it away, I sexed it away
I read it away

Beyoncé is the perfect site of exploration for these questions, because she represents the merging of two worlds that have typically been unallowed to meet: Beyoncé is the elite, seemingly untouched by the problems facing the majority of people on this earth, and she is Black. This raises the question - how does a racist culture revere a black goddess? Parker’s poems suggest that Beyoncé has been treated like a vessel – for a robotic nature of femininity, for Lady Gaga. She has been so eroded of any kind of interiority that Parker cannot even imagine that Beyoncé is honest with her own therapist. And even when Beyoncé asks questions, taking on a voice of her own, the result is poignant and brief. Consider, for instance, “Beyoncé Celebrates Black History Month”:

“I have almost
forgotten my roots
are not long
blond. I have almost forgotten
what it means to be at sea.”

This poem is so clever, the line breaks so brilliant. Because even in this admission, Beyoncé is evading. The sentence doesn’t end with, “I have almost forgotten my roots.” or even “I have almost forgotten my roots / are not long,” both of which conjure associations of ancestry and lineage. But in the next line, it is revealed that the roots are simply strands of blonde hair. Of course, the poem holds all the meanings simultaneously, but it is telling that Beyonce cannot talk about her roots without also implicating her hair.  

Throughout these poems, there is a hunger for something different. A utopic day when “your shit will be unbelievably together.” Parker writes: “One day you’ll care a whole lot you’ll always take vitamins / And exercise without bragging and words will fit perfectly / Into your mouth like an olive soaked in gin / The glory of an olive soaked in gin and its smooth smallness” (76). It’s a utopia that still relies on alcohol as medicine and metaphor. It’s a utopia that can perhaps only be tasted in small doses. I think back to the last line of “So What” that asks why you get up in the morning and has no punctuation. I think about how the absence of a question mark holds space, offers room for something else to be created. And then I remember the closing lines from “Poem on Beyonce’s Birthday”: “Today your open eyes are two fresh buds / Anything could be waiting.”

Morgan Park Response


I found a lot of the duality of social intersections being written about beautifully by Morgan Parker. In a lot of the poems in her collection we get a sense of some social navigation going on with her identity as black and woman and of a certain generation where the phenomenon of Beyonce has given strength to so many but has also been, I think for Parker too, a benchmark that is near impossible to reach.

And at the same time Parker is musing Beyonce’s identity too in a way with poems such as Poems written on Beyonce’s birthday which I found was a little poignant with the line “drinking cough syrup from a glass shaped like your body I wish was mine but as dark as something in my mind telling me I’m not woman enough for these days” here Parker seems to be getting at the social intersection of her identity as a black woman, and how there are impossible societal standards that were not made to be achieved by every American woman. Only by white women.

I found this sentiment in the third poem of her collection too with her line “I will never be woman enough” and it reminds me of the speech by Sojouner Truth entitled “ain’t I a woman too” in which she stood up in the face of many white people to declare that her being black wasn’t negating her status as woman too.

Parker also takes the time to realize her own identity as a multiplicity of sorts, a recognition that there are both good and bad parts to everyone. I loved that line from the first poem “I do whatever I want because I could die any minute/ I don’t mean YOLO I mean they are hunting me” I definitely resonated with that because there is this sense of freedom that is uninhibited but underneath there is a grim truth that ripples there. Parker ends her first poem with the lines “I am a tree and some fruit are good and some are bad”

Beyonce on the line for Gaga was a very threaded poem because it intertwines the cultural phenomenon of Beyonce and Gaga and to me, seemed like a poetic fan fictional account on a conversation between them. I saw Beyonce represented in the words “divas getting money” and “soft brown fingers” and I saw Gaga being represented by “glitter” and “Littler monsters” both lines have cultural significance to their representations in popular culture.

I also really enjoyed The Origin of the Universe poem, it was written in this narrative block style and had minimal line breaks, which I think was good for the energy and flow of the poem. I was caught by the line
“one day we learned to migrate. One day we studied/Mamma making her face./ Bright new Brown…” I found these lines profound because of the perspective represented here. We go from migration which is what many black people in America did once slavery was abolished, from the south to the north. Then we go to Mamma, which is zoomed into as a personal poetic tie, who is the origin of the universe.

And then I found a certain reclaiming of the word ‘brown’ here. Brown being bright, which is a tone of the color not often talked about, especially when applied to people.

Parker goes on in the collection to continue this metaphor of brown being bright and I loved that. I saw it again in My Vinyl Weighs a Ton where she gives description of the morning “…into the brown morning” in a later poem we even get “brown flower petals”
I also really appreciated the s sounds in the first line of that poem “sit down shut up slip me out of my sleeve” I found the poetic quality very high there


I found that Parker also played a lot with spacing in this collection of poems. I am thinking abut Delicate and Jumpy where the poem is given to us in couplets that seem to jump from one stanza to the next. “Turns out I feel my body/more than I should. My eyes dart

Like a small animal. I’m a museum…” with the space Parker gives, its like she is simultaneously creating space for the poem to shift.

I also saw spacing being played with in Take a Walk on the Wild Side where the spacing seems to be based on colloquialism.
“I feel the bass you-know-where                                            Exactly” like the stress of that line is on the word exactly

I also thought about spacing a lot when it came to the poem 99 Problems and about spacing and the ways to achieve a poem, by using its best form.

I saw the title’s allusion to the Jay-Z song of the same title. I like that the collection had so many hip-hop references
We even start with a quote from Kendrick Lamar who is a Pulitzer prize winning artist for his album DAMN which features a song entitled xxx, in which we get the story of a black person trying to win but failing to do so because of the social conditions he is placed under.

I loved the way social identity and the cultural phenomenon of Beyonce (self-identity and/v.s pop culture) were intertwined to make a beautiful statement on life.

Friday, February 1, 2019

Morgan Parker's Humor and Language in There are Things More Beautiful Than Beyonce

I appreciate Morgan Parker’s self-deprecating humor as a poet. In “Heaven Be a Xanax,” the speaker cries in the Gap by her therapist’s office, which seems devastating and uncontrollable until Parker wields some humor: “Am I still angry with my parents / for traumatizing me / through organized sports” (lines 5-7). I mean, the line break between “traumatizing” and “organized sports” is a short-lived cliff hanger with some impeccable comedic timing. It is a quick “suspense for the sake of suspense” line break. It’s your classic misdirect. These three lines function the way pain moves as a force through our bodies... pain curls up and gets comfortable, but it makes us hiss in self-defense when someone gets too close (even when we ourselves get too close… we have to laugh-push ourselves away).


I deeply appreciate Parker’s ability to name desire in her own body, which so often for women is overlooked and/or worse, discarded by members of society. Women of color are often portrayed by the media as a whole suite of harmful stereotypes, few of which convey a healthy desire nor strong sense of desirability. In “Beyoncé on the line for Gaga,” Parker claims the space of her body through nature: “You feel me? This booty / is smooth running water.” In the span of two lines, Parker creates motion and texture with a stream… this is striking and powerful to me. Streams are interminable, ever-shifting, quiet yet persistent forces of nature that can carve through the hardest rock. This part of her body is reclaimed and renamed as something deeply natural and tied to the earth.


I love what Parker does with spaces. Sometimes, her spaces feel like bleeped-out words, like what you imagine you hear/read, but don’t actually encounter beyond your mind. Implied language. In “Lush Life,” Parker’s spaces perform a different function. For me, the spaces feel like a hard swallow… the kind of steeling yourself you do when you’re about to reveal something heavy. My favorite white-space is after “I could rot here” in line 12. Rotting is so ugly on the surface, but she renders it beautiful in this line because of its parallel associations: I could melt here. I could die here. I could stay here forever.


Know what else strikes me about Parker? Her language. Her use of sound. I’ll most likely riff on this in every blog (apologies-not-apologies in advance), but in “Lush Life,” Parker wields sound, particularly in the latter half of the poem with the long “s” sounds: “bruised ice,” “self-stirred,” “sleep,” barstool,” “smooth,” “black sand.”


“S” sounds are especially soporific and lulling… I would argue that they are tied right into a universally human representation of water. All you have to do is say “sssss” to someone on a long car trip, and they have to pee. I mean, come on. “S” is water. “S” is constant, a stream flowing. “S” is not a harsh or fighting sound, like “ck” in “mock crowds” or “rrr” in “murder.”


All in all, I am intrigued by Parker’s use of humor and language in her work… it felt accessible and verse-like to read. All you have to do is contrast this with someone like Yeats (if you are feeling ridiculous and up for strange comparisons) and you’ll feel how much more “on the tongue” Parker’s poetry feels than somebody (anybody, especially Yeats) born in the 19th/20th centuries… in terms of form, in terms of tone, in terms of content… everything.